By Jeff Todd
Dr. Art McDonald is unique in his appreciation for philanthropy.
After all, he wasn’t born a Nobel Prize winning physicist. Before reaching the pinnacle of his profession 2015, Dr. McDonald was the recipient of an endowed chair at Queen’s University, courtesy of philanthropists Gordon and Patricia Gray, giving him the opportunity to pursue cutting-edge research. Two years after it ended, he would accept the Nobel Prize.
Years earlier, he benefited from the Killam Prize, given to Canada’s top scholars. Named after Dorothy Killam, she used her vast fortune to support education and research in her will.
But on Easter Sunday this year, another act of philanthropy would be particularly unique, and leave the eminent scientist “flabbergasted”.
It started with a phone call on the holiday weekend to Donald and Robert Sobey, owners of the second largest food retailer in Canada. Except this call wasn’t about food, or even Particle Astrophysics.
It was about how philanthropists could help develop a new, low-cost ventilator to save lives amid the COVID-19 pandemic.
“The generosity of the individuals who helped us and their immediate response … I was flabbergasted,” Dr. McDonald said, who currently serves as Professor Emeritus at Queen’s University and won the Nobel Prize for his research into the mysteries of dark matter.
“I came away from those phone calls blessed by the response of those donors. It just made it possible for us to proceed. It was a race against time.”
This race began just a month earlier, in the very teeth of the pandemic.
A chance to make a contribution
Back in March, Dr. McDonald was contacted by Italian physicist and colleague Cristiano Galbiati, who was in lockdown in Milan, one of the virus’ epicenters at this time. He realized that elements of the technology they were developing in their particle experiments could potentially be applied to a new type of ventilator, one that can be produced quickly and at a lower cost.
In fact, whereas a typical ventilator may contain 15,00 parts, the proposed prototype would be just 50 core parts. Up to 1,000 units could be manufactured in a month.
With the virus spreading rapidly all around the world, experts soon realized there would be a shortage of PPE and ventilators to treat patients. While it may not have been Dr. McDonald’s usual area of expertise, here was a chance to make a contribution to the crisis, he thought.
But they needed help. Working with his Italian colleagues, Dr. McDonald rallied the troops. He connected with TRIUMF in Vancouver, Canada’s major particle accelerator centre and a premier physics laboratory. He also reached out to Canadian Nuclear Laboratories in Chalk River, Ontario, SNOLAB, an underground facility in Sudbury specializing in neutrino and dark matter physics and academic colleagues in Canada associated with the McDonald Institute, specializing in Astroparticle physics.
Suddenly, some of the best minds in the world were rallied in the fight against around COVID-19.
“All of them immediately said: ’Whatever you need. We will be very willing to help out with this situation’,” he remembers.
“When we got into it, it was quite clear people with a wide variety of skills were pleased to apply them to do something positive to try and help.”
This international gathering of the minds, all volunteers, produced a functioning prototype at astonishing speed – 10 days.
Finding a way to manufacture a full scale, reliable and safe product, however, was another matter.
Dubbed the MVM Ventilator Project, Dr. McDonald and the international team set about finding companies that could actually manufacture the product, deciding on Vexos in Markham, Ontario, and JMP Solutions in London, Ontario and Elemaster in Italy.
In a true act of philanthropy, Dr. McDonald and his colleagues didn’t seek personal gain from the project. All of the research was deemed “open source”, effectively allowing any company in the world to use the design for the benefit of their communities.
Certainly, Canada was paying attention
In early April, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced that Dr. McDonald and his team would be one of four suppliers that government could engage for ventilators, with the goal of boosting the country’s stockpile by more than 30,000 units.
So with a working prototype in hand, and a possible order from the Canadian government, the MVM Ventilator Project was off and running. It was a waiting game now, for the ventilators to receive full approval from Health Canada. There was just one problem.
“With the demand for ventilators everywhere in the world, many critical components were in short supply,” Dr. McDonald explains.
“The companies supplying them were saying, ’fine, you can purchase them, but we want a full financial commitment’. The government contract was 10,000 devices, but in April we needed to come up with the money to secure these components.”
So on that Sunday morning on Easter Weekend, Donald and Rob Sobey gladly accepted the Nobel Laureates’ call. While both from the Maritimes, Donald and Rob were also Queen’s University graduates, where Dr. McDonald has been a Professor since 1989.
By the end of the conversation, the Donald Sobey Foundation had made a substantial donation to secure the critical parts, paving the way for one of the most unique and timely partnerships in recent memory.
“I think the world is upside down,” Rob Sobey, a trustee of the Donald Sobey Foundation, told CTV News in April.
“Everything is back to front. And here is a really great example of science working with business to come up with new collaborations to get things done. To save lives. This is nothing more than saving lives. I think everyone hopes these ventilators won’t be needed. But it is certainly better to have them and not need them, than the other way around.”
Dr. McDonald’s next call was to Peter Nicholson Sr., the Chairman of The Foundation WCPD.
In addition to being a noted economist, advisor to multiple Canadian prime ministers and an Order of Canada recipient, Nicholson had also been Dr. McDonald’s college roommate at Dalhousie University, and the best man at his wedding.
Nicholson immediately referred him to his son, Peter Nicholson Jr., the President and Founder of The Foundation WCPD. As someone who lives and breathes philanthropy, here was someone that could reach more donors.
Since 2006, The Foundation WCPD, a boutique financial services firm, has worked with Canada’s largest philanthropists by using flow-through shares to help them give up to three times more than a standard donation, at no additional cost. The firm combines two long-established tax policies, one to assist Canada’s resource sector to create jobs and produce raw materials, and another to give Canadians a tax break for donations to charity, or your standard tax receipt.
What it adds up to is more than $150 million in charitable donations by its clients to charities all across Canada.
“I immediately wanted to help,” Nicholson Jr. said, whose company is headquartered in Ottawa. “I have been working with philanthropists for a long time, but this call was special. It was truly humbling to be asked and have the ability to help.”
In addition to making a personal donation, Nicholson quickly set up meetings with other philanthropists over Easter Weekend. The Garrett Family Foundation, Josh Felker, Dan Robichaud, Patricia Saputo, Salvatore Guerrera, Nicola Tedeschi, and four anonymous donors all contributed to the effort, as did the Lazaridis Family Foundation in answer to a personal contact from Prof. McDonald.
The Foundation WCPD’s tax structure helped boost the donations for some of these donors.
“Flow-through shares not only place a significant lever on your giving, but they also allow us clients to quickly laser those donations to a charity of their choice,” he explains.
Speed, as Mr. McDonald said, was indeed the name of the game. With close to a million dollars in donations now secured, over a holiday weekend, his group could now guarantee the parts needed for the new, life-saving technology.
He also noted that some of the donations, held at Queen’s University in the Dr. Art McDonald Ventilator Research Fund, have been used to purchase a human lung simulator to help test the effectiveness of the new technology. Once COVID-19 has passed, the equipment will be donated to the medical school, he said.
Dr. McDonald also wishes to use some of the donations to assist patients internationally, in places such as South America and Africa, where countries are more less equipped and unable to treat the population.
Meanwhile, with Health Canada’s approval now secured, production has now begun on 10,000 low cost, easy to manufacture ventilators — just in time.
As Canada settles in for a long winter, and the “second wave” of COVID-19 sweeps the country, and the world, Dr. McDonald says he is both amazed and thankful to the donors for their rapid response. He adds that the ability to go from idea, to final design, to approval within regulatory agencies in just six months is “almost unheard of”, and a testament to society’s ability to pull together in times of crisis.
“I got the immediate impression of the big hearts who were making these quick decisions to support us,” Dr. McDonald said.
“I think it is quite unique in terms of the instant response on the part of the donors, at a very critical time for us. Their decisions were clearly made with a humanitarian objective, and I think we have been able to deliver on that vision.”
Jeff Todd is Communications Director at Foundation WCPD.